Okay, so I'm a huge fan of American Idol. I've been watching it since....I think, Fantasia's season. They had it ON on our honeymoon night, haha!
It took me a few days to recover from my huge disappointment over the Top 13. I was rooting for Hallie Day and Creighton Fraker. I always have a soft spot for struggling artists. Maybe because I've lived it, too, at one "long" point in my life.
Here are some of my thoughts on SOME of the most colorful contestants in the Semi-Finals:
REED GRIMM. He's a genius in music, that's pretty obvious. I really enjoyed his rearrangement of "Moves like Jagger" and my guess is, he also had a hand in the music arrangement of that
thousand eyes and
hold up I'm coming (sorry, I don't know the titles) songs he did with the other contestants on Hollywood week. It's just that, everytime the music stops, he acts strangely and annoyingly childish.I think they tried to give him a chance to show off more of his vocal skills, like in a ballad or something, but he didn't get it. Hey, I'm all for entertainment, but American Idol is first and foremost, a singing competition.
HALLIE DAY. She was my favorite. I thought she would be Top 12. Nope, I didn't think she'd win, Philip Philips already had that in the bag from the beginning. But I know those pipes have more to offer than what's been showcased. Too bad she got voted out early. She could've done better with that song! I think that she's oozing with sex appeal,too, like a human Jessica Rabbit. What wildcard should've been Hallie's went to Brielle. What a waste!
JESSICA SANCHEZ. Finally, a Pinay on the American Idol stage who can actually deliver! Not sure if she's appealing enough to get the votes to win but she's definitely got two minority groups in America behind her as long as she continues to set that stage on fire. For those who do not know, Jessica is Filipina-Mexican, she's not purely Filipino.Not that it matters.
CREIGHTON FRAKER. What can I say? (Sigh)I like "True Colors" but I knew it was going to get him in trouble. Despite the amazing vocal arrangement in the end, it was still the wrong song to sing on such a critical night! He does have that screechy quality in his voice at times, but that can be fixed. One of the other two wildcards should've been for Creighton. I still think that this guy has so much musical talent.
HEEJUN HAN. I think this guy's got a really smooth voice,I give him that, I just don't know what else he's got to offer and how far it'll take him. I'm a bit worried that he won't be able to pull off other music genres, especially the uptempo ones. He's very charming on TV, though. He's got the viewers hanging around for his next funny line. I think that popularity-wise, he's gonna give Philip Philips a run for the title. Highlighting their "bro-mance" by the way, is a brilliant move by the producers. I won't be surprised if, at the beginning, they orchestrated for this to develop the way it did. What a finale it would be if Heejun Han and Jessica Sanchez would be there! But then again, Philip Philips almost already secured his spot, so there's only room for one more.
PHILIP PHILIPS. I'm not a fan. I don't like growlers. But I think he's going to win. He's good-looking and I see that people, the judges included, like his style. I like his personality, if that counts.
JEN HIRSH. I think that she should get back together with Creighton, Aaron, Reed and that spectacled guy that was kicked off during Hollywood round 2. Now, that would be very interesting and enjoyable to watch. She's an awesome vocalist, but I can understand how she didn't appeal to the voters. I can't explain it though...I guess, X-factor?
EBEN FRANCKEWITZ. I like this kid. That voice was pure and still raw. Whoever advised him to do that Adelle song forgot to teach him dynamics to his rendition.The song came out plain and straight. With all the notes flying high that night from the other contestants, his performance just wasn't strong enough.
ELISE TESTONE. She's a good singer with a great, big a'voice. But I hear so many of those, lately, so I've yet to appreciate her.
HALEY JOHNSEN. After watching her performance on YouTube over and over again, I finally understood what she was trying to do. At first I thought she was out of tune and I found myself cringing till her last note. At first, I thought she couldn't find the melody with all the known sound sytem problems they've been having in AI. But I realized, she chose not to sing the melody! She sang the back-up notes instead so she can show off her vocal calisthenics which I think was...well, it's something. Seriously, I think this girl knows the notes, it just didn't come off well. I've been replaying the song in my head with all the right dynamics and the creativity is actually impressive. There was a lot of shouting in the high parts and so much lack of control, it made my throat feel a little uncomfortable.In these kinds of competition, you gotta sound correct the first time the voters hear you. It was a risk not worth taking. It's like she grabbed the "worst performance of the night" throne from Bailey Brown in a matter of minutes, which was sad. She is a much better singer and performer than she came out.
HOLLIE CAVANAGH. Okay, she's not bad. She just went off-key a couple of times. AI producers should really do something with that sound sytem problem they have! Hollie sounds like a kid fresh off her voice lessons. Her notes were round, the vocal placement in-line. She was too technical for my taste.
ADAM BROCK. His constant crying overshadowed his singing skills. Whoever said people like seeing a grown man cry?
DEANDRE & JEREMY. ZZZzzzzz. I'm not interested; Maybe Jeremy has more potential on surprising me? Jennifer Lopez lays her credibility on the line for this guy, he'd better deliver!
Have you heard of The Boss or Brix from the Philippines? Those are my standards for good singing falsetto. They're not even the biggest stars here but Deandre pales in comparison.
COLTON DIXON. Oh yeah, there's him, too....he'll probably land in the Top 5. He'd better redeem his little sister. Much of the attention he's reaping now was at her expense. Seriously, this was supposedly her year-- he wasn't going to audition, but he's getting all the lovin'. I think she deserves the redemption.
(Photo courtesy of http://www.wetpaint.com/american-idol/gallery/american-idols-top-13-finalists-party-with-the-judges-in-la-photos#5)